S85B50
"The S85 is heavily inspired by F1 engines — it's extremely important to have proper oil pressure. You can't just turn the keys and go."
Rod Bearing Failure / Crankshaft Bearing WearCRITICAL
The S85 has a well-documented tendency toward rod and main bearing failure, often leading to total engine destruction. The engine's F1-derived design demands constant adequate oil pressure; any lapse — cold starts driven hard, low oil level, or extended intervals — accelerates bearing wear catastrophically. High-mileage examples are especially vulnerable.
Throttle Actuator Failure (SMG Gear Motor / Throttle Body)HIGH
The S85 uses ten individual throttle bodies, each with actuator gearing and MOSFET control boards that are prone to wear and failure. This is described as an 'infamous' and well-known issue in the community. Replacement of the gearing and MOSFET components is a documented repair, but parts and labor costs are significant.
Elevated Oil TemperatureHIGH
Forum data indicates oil temperature running high in warmer conditions and under spirited driving. The oil cooling system must be fully functional; a compromised oil cooler, thermostat, or blocked passages leads to accelerated bearing and engine wear given the S85's tight tolerances.
SMG Transmission Reliability ConcernsMODERATE
The E60 M5 was equipped with the SMG III sequential manual gearbox, which has its own reliability concerns separate from the engine but closely linked to ownership experience. Community data notes the SMG clutch and actuators need monitoring, particularly on higher-mileage examples.
Cold Start Oil Pressure RiskMODERATE
Due to the F1-inspired design, the S85 requires careful cold-start procedure. Driving hard before the engine reaches full operating temperature — especially oil temperature — is a primary cause of premature bearing wear. This is an ongoing operational risk throughout the engine's life, not a mileage-specific failure.
The BMW E60 M5 S85 is one of the greatest naturally aspirated performance engines ever built, but it demands respect, knowledge, and financial readiness. Buy only a car with a fully documented, short-interval service history using the correct 10W-60 specification oil — anything less and bearing failure becomes a near certainty. Budget €2,000-4,000 immediately for a thorough mechanical inspection, proactive bearing check, and any deferred maintenance, and set aside a substantial reserve for the inevitable high-cost repairs this engine will eventually require. This is a car for enthusiasts who will maintain it properly, not a budget used car purchase.