BMW/S63
BMW · Naturally aspirated

S63

M5·F10·20112016

"BMW's V8s just aren't reliable or remotely affordable to maintain. The hot-v turbo setup that the N63 and S63 use is known to be problematic."

RISKY
42/ 100
"Hot-vee heartbreak, expensive to own right"
Max HP
Torque Nm
10,000
Oil interval km
0
Recalls
6
Known issues
Known Issues
Excessive Oil Consumption (Valve Stem Seals / Piston Rings)€2,000-5,000 · 30,000-100,000 kmCRITICAL

The S63 shares the N63's notorious oil consumption problem rooted in the hot-vee layout. Valve stem seals degrade prematurely due to extreme heat from the turbos sitting inside the V. This led to a class-action lawsuit against BMW. Dealers replaced piston rings under extended warranty but consumption often persisted. Some owners report losing 1L per 200–1,000 km.

Oil level dropping between services
Low oil warning light illuminating
Blue smoke on startup or under load
Burning oil smell from engine bay
DIY: HARD
Turbocharger Heat Soak and Premature Wear€3,000-8,000 · 60,000-150,000 kmHIGH

The hot-vee design places both turbochargers inside the engine V, exposing them to extreme radiant heat. This accelerates turbo bearing wear and can cause oil coking in turbo feed lines if oil changes are neglected or if the engine is shut down immediately after hard use.

Turbo whine or rattling at idle
Reduced boost pressure
Smoke on boost
Oil leaks from turbo lines
DIY: HARD
EGR Cooler Failure€600-1,500 · 50,000-120,000 kmHIGH

EGR cooler cracking and leaking is a documented issue on BMW V8 engines of this era. A cracked cooler can introduce coolant into the intake or cause coolant loss, potentially leading to overheating if undetected.

Coolant loss with no visible external leak
White smoke from exhaust
EGR-related fault codes (e.g. 4873)
Coolant reservoir requiring frequent top-up
DIY: MODERATE
Oil Cooler Seal and Valley Pan Leaks€800-2,000 · 60,000-130,000 kmMODERATE

The oil cooler seals and coolant valley pan located deep in the engine V are prone to leaking due to sustained high operating temperatures. Access requires significant disassembly, making labour costs the dominant expense.

Oil or coolant pooling beneath the engine
Mixing of oil and coolant
Oily residue inside the engine valley
DIY: HARD
Charge Air Cooler / Intercooler Degradation€500-1,500 · 80,000-160,000 kmMODERATE

The stock intercoolers on the S63 are known to become a limiting factor, especially if the car is used on track or driven hard. Heat soak reduces charge cooling efficiency, leading to power loss and increased knock.

Power loss during extended spirited driving
Increased fuel consumption
Knock retard visible on data logging
DIY: MODERATE
High General Maintenance Costs€500-1,500 · 0-200,000 kmLOW

Beyond specific failures, routine maintenance on the S63 is expensive due to its complexity. Spark plugs, fuel injectors, belts, and ancillaries all require specialist access and carry premium part costs.

Misfires from aged spark plugs
Rough idle
Increased fuel consumption over time
DIY: MODERATE
Advertisement
Buying Checklist
Commission an independent oil consumption test over 2,000–3,000 km before purchasing — budget accordingly if consuming over 0.5L per 1,000 km
Pull a full OBD fault code scan including stored and pending codes, specifically checking for EGR, boost, and oil pressure faults
Request documented proof of valve stem seal and/or piston ring work under the BMW extended warranty or class-action settlement
Inspect the engine valley visually and with a flashlight for oil seepage around the valley pan and oil cooler seals
Verify the service history shows oil changes at no more than 10,000 km intervals with an approved BMW LL-01 spec oil
Test drive under full load on a motorway ramp — listen for turbo whine, check for blue smoke in mirrors, and confirm boost feels strong and consistent
Service Reality
Community oil interval10,000 km
Oil specificationBMW LL-01 0W-40 or 5W-40 fully synthetic (e.g. Castrol Edge, Liqui Moly 5W-40)
Est. ownership cost (2yr)€3,000–7,000 per year including maintenance, consumables, and likely repair of at least one major oil or turbo-related issue within a 3-year ownership window
Real fuel consumptionNo data
Also Found In
BMW X5 M (F85)BMW X6 M (F86)BMW M6 (F12/F13/F06)Alpina B5 (F10 variant)
Buying Advice

The F10 M5's S63 engine is a genuinely exciting unit that can be reliable when properly maintained, but it shares the N63's core structural weaknesses around oil consumption, turbo heat soak, and sealing failures in the engine valley. Pre-purchase oil consumption testing is non-negotiable — walk away from any car the seller refuses to test. Budget a minimum of €2,000–4,000 as a contingency fund for valve stem seals or turbo work within the first year of ownership. This is a car for enthusiasts who research thoroughly and maintain obsessively, not a casual used performance buy.

Parts People Buy
S63 / N63 Valve Stem Seal SetLink unavailable
BMW LL-01 5W-40 Fully Synthetic Engine OilLink unavailable
S63 Oil Cooler Seal KitLink unavailable
BMW S63 EGR CoolerLink unavailable
S63 Upgraded Charge Air Cooler / IntercoolerLink unavailable
BMW S63 Spark Plug SetLink unavailable
* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Advertisement